Many things have DR pierce (some spiders, rakshasas) and the puncturing effect only comes on rapiers, which, although seldomly used now, can still be useful. They clearly made them light for one reason and one reason only. Where as the other had that wide cleaver type blade. Dungeons & Dragons vs. Rick and Morty Frozen Sick Ghosts of Saltmarsh Hoard of the Dragon Queen ... Proficiency with a scimitar allows you to add your proficiency bonus to the attack roll for any attack you make with it. More specifically, the weight of the blade is balanced at the base of the hilt. The rapier either finds it's way around armour, or pierces through weak points. Comments. A rapier's blade is ~38 inches. What? 1d6. Agreed, ACTUAL scimitars should not be but seeing as how this is D&D (and while I did say that D&D usually favors realism when it comes to weapons and combat, its still a game) they can flub a few things. These are items built for the purpose of fighting, so only those who are trained to fight with them are proficient. For the Dark Souls II variant, see Scimitar (Dark Souls II). They aren't conducive to being dual-wielded. [5e] Why is a Short Sword (3lbs) "light", but a Rapier (2lbs) isn't? Both are finess weapons, and though the scimitar is more fluid and better for skirmishing (light, 1d6), the rapier does edge it out in range and has more force behind its blows (1d8). Rapier (2d4, not light) vs Scimitar (1d6, light), why the change? It requires an Attack level of 40 to wield. There's debate on exact sizes and all, for preference of use and size of the wielder, etc, but... yeah. Damage Type. And why does it do 2d4 damage? I ask because I'm looking to shift my Hexblade to two-weapon fighting, but currently she's stuck with a rapier. They are however, finesse weapons. The basket-hilted sword was … 2-3lbs isn't light? HiJustHi. I do agree that scimitars should be neither light nor finesse weapons though. Rapiers have an edge, an epee does not. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Scimitars (pronounced \"sim-i-tar\") are a type of slash weapon that can also be used as a stab weapon, although less effectively. Hard to extend both arms as far as you can twist your body to extend the one arm. Orientalischer Säbel mit Klinge aus Kohlenstoffstahl. This is just my two cents, and my only experience/knowledge is playing around with my friend's training swords and having him show me a few things. It's really, really hard. Feels like a lot for a rapier. Small characters (gnomes and halflings) may not finesse rapiers though, since they wield rapiers with both hands. Scimitar is a Weapon in Dark Souls 3. The Mace is one of the few that is explicitly a weapon, but is very simple in execution like a club, resulting in the simple categorization. In addition, you can make one Attack with it as a Bonus Action on each of your turns. The rapier is a very thin sword, most effective for piercing. Yes, I want my cake and eat it too. Side note: the weight listing for ANYTHING in D&D has always been horribly, terribly weird. BUT, I'm no expert.-Josey . Notes: Bonus: Magic, Extra Attack as Bonus Action, Damage, Combat, Finesse, Light. Basic Rules , pg. In terms of accessibility to the user for programming the modifiable button functions, the Razer synapse program is easier to use, the changeable side panel with different button configurations make the mouse itself far more customizable than the Scimitar, and the buttons of the macro block in the Scimitar are flush and close together, making them hard to distinguish from one another during use. Light is a game term more than a literal description of weight. There is also a members-only scimitar shop located in the Ape Atoll that is only available after completing the Monkey Madness quest. 1 Notes 2 Toolset 3 Black rider quill 4 Bleederkin 5 Mercykiller blade 6 Namarra (neversleep) +1 7 Namarra (neversleep) +2 8 Namarra (neversleep) +8 9 Rapier of the high road Rapiers are the only medium-sized weapons that benefit from weapon finesse. Rapier is Piercing, Scimitar is Slashing; Rapier is a bonus weapon for Elves, and is part of the Rogue weapon set, while Scimitar belongs to the Druid set. The scimitar uses it's curved edge and weight to slash through light armour. Yes, I want to make derpy Drzz't clones. A quarterstaff has a damage die of 1d6 when wielded one-handed and 1d8 when wielded two-handed. Basically, it's saying "This weapon can be dual wielded", it has nothing to do with the size or weight of the weapon. OSRS Melee Max Hit Calc - Dragon Warhammer max hit, Godswords, supports all popular weapons, special attacks and other bonuses. Prior to the addition of the Brine sabre, the rapier and rune scimitar were tied for best-in-slot melee weapon for 40 attack-tier weaponry .. Page 4 of 4 < Prev 1 2 3 4 It would take a lot of training to effectively dual-wield two longswords or rapiers and still use them as they were intended to be used, and the Dual-wielder feat that allows you to do so represents that extra, unique training. Longsword vs Katana, Rapier vs Scimitar, CUTTING VS THRUSTING? Spears/javelins/quarterstaves/short bows/slings are likely to be known by most commoners if they've ever had need to hunt for food or defend against wild animals to protect their animals or themselves. Waahhh wahhh waahhh. In the game, the rapier classically flaunts a high crit range with middling damage to represent it can normally inflict moderate harm and can be lethal with precise thrusts, while the scimitar consistently does above average damage and is essentially your finesseable longsword. Among modern sword collectors and historians the term is not frequently used, as it does not well describe a particular typology of blade, although the term was indeed used historically. Attributes Damage. I think the difference between the two is that the swords euro counterpart (saber) has a less pronounced curve and a thinner blade. Can you dual wield a shortsword/rapier/dagger and a flintlock pistol in 5e? Rustikal verarbeitet. If not, I must correct you. Item Type . Estoc definition, a thrusting sword of the 13th–17th centuries having a long, narrow blade of rectangular section. Scimitar! At 2 pounds. Learn swords before you rant, please. Scimitars and shortswords, on the other hand, are slashing weapons, and there's none of that stretching yourself to attack, so its easy to twirl around with two blades. Just saying. Pikes represent the long spears within the game, with the added reach and 1d10 damage instead of 1d6/1d8. In the same vein, why does a Spear not have Reach? Note: This is ONLY to be used to report spam, advertising, and problematic (harassment, fighting, or rude) posts. Item Tags: Damage Combat. There's debate on exact sizes and all, for preference of use and size of the wielder, etc, but... yeah. Its stats are comparable to a rune scimitar but with the stab and slash attack bonuses inverted.. In den Warenkorb. I have always held to the thought that scimitars are designed to be used differently than a Rapier, and that "light" just means easily wielded. A scimitar's blade is ~34 inches. TL;DR I want to power-game without making sacrifices for asthetic reasons. I likewise would be happy to allow Longsword/rapier (or hell battleaxe/warhammer) and an off hand dagger. TL;DR I want to power-game without making sacrifices for asthetic reasons. Item Rarity. Thus did scimitar originally refer to a broad family of swords, of which there are now identified many individual types. Discussion in ' Weapons and Tactics ' started by marceloISbest , Nov 6, 2011 . Yes, I want to make derpy Drzz't clones. Rules don't have to make complete sense, but I think this actually gets pretty close. Versand. In our game we switched to damage dice and made Rapier the light weapon, it just doesn't make sense that Scimitar is light while the rapier is not. Slashing. The Scimitar is a curved sword in Dark Souls. It requires an Attack level of 40 to wield. Assume samey stuff is the same. A scimitar is basically a finessable longsword. Edit: Additional considerations, pretty much all of the simple weapons are items that can conceivably be related to mundane items used for manual labor and/or hunting. 199. This shop sells dragon scimitars. As far as why a scimitar is light, while a rapier isn't... game balance. an in-game excuse, I'd say "length of attack". Tldr, the rapier will be better in the assassinate scenario but otherwise the shortsword is better. The scimitar's flesh-rending slash atacks are greatly compromised against armor and tough scale-covered hides. Mainly, it is of course game balance, as people have already said - but if you are looking for verisimilitude in the rules, i.e. It was used by Gentleman Mallard until his disappearance at sea. They chose to make spears versatile, and have the thrown property. My heart says the longswordsman, but my head says it has to go to the rapier-wielder. 1 Availability 2 Characteristics 3 Moveset 4 Upgrades 5 Gallery Wanderer class starting weapon. All trademarks are property of their respective owners in the US and other countries. All rights reserved. Martial weapons for the most part are weapons of war, items specifically designed to separate them from simple tools that can be used as weapons, built and designed for battle and the slaying of enemies. But in actuality, dual hand crossbow with Crossbow Expert is the way to go. Small curved sword that excels in swift movements and consecutive attacks. What exactly determines a "Light" weapon? Scimitar Vs Rapier 5e List of all unique magical items. Scimitar. I'd honestly say rapiers; All crit effects come on pierce (excluding vorpal, which is technically a crit effect). New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. © Valve Corporation. And if you're TWF then you're probably gonna settle for Shortswords anyway...unless you want more feat tax, which is crazy. I think the "lightness" of a scimitar comes from its ease of use; it's a lot easier to swing two blades around as slashing weapons than it is to make proper rapier thrusts with both hands. : 61013 Lieferzeit: 1-3 Tage 87,68 EUR inkl. I was talking PnP so no stat cap there...also I was assuming all factors that can be will be the same. And why does it only do 1d6 damage? But the Scimitar is considered Light, at 3 pounds. A Rapier may weigh about the same as a Scimitar, but you only get to stab with it (cuts don't work with a Rapier) so you have to control the point of this long, light metal needle with your off hand while also using a weapon in the other hand. A light weapon is small and easy to handle, making it ideal for use when fighting with two weapons. Skill: Spin Slash Slice into foes with a large spinning motion, and follow with strong attack for a spinning vertical-slash. Most of which involved a family heirloom, a lost past or something like that. Its stats are the same as the rune scimitar but with the stab and slash attack bonuses swapped. The Razer Nagais the win… Axes/daggers/sickles are the same, all having uses for mundane tasks in every day life, but also able to be used to defend oneself if needed. Mortuary swords remained in use until around 1670 when they fell out of favor among civilians and began to be replaced with the smallsword.[10]. Dual wielding rapiers is not. Because the dual wielding scimitar dervish is a classic archetype in fantasy. Rapiers aren't light and shouldn't be. Re: Scimitar and rapier Originally Posted by Gnomes2169 I would also like to point out that aside from a few arrogant nobles being arrogant, the rapier was pretty much a dueling only weapon that denoted status, not a weapon that was brought to and used on the battlefield. You can only two-weapon if both weapons are Light, and the rapier isn't a "Light" weapon. sabre . Why is a scimitar a light weapon? Some might say that a Scimitar is about as long as an Armingsword (Longsword in D&D), but its optimal attack-range isn't; it is a poor stabbing weapon vs. armour and is meant to cut from about 1/3 down the blade - and unlike an Armingsword you don't really chop, you "draw" your blade across your enemy. Español - Latinoamérica (Spanish - Latin America). For the Dark Souls III variant, see Scimitar (Dark Souls III). Likely this was to imply that a weapon with range long enough to grant reach would require more training/martial prowess resulting in it no longer being classified as a "simple" weapon. dnd 5e rapier vs shortsword. Rapier vs. +1 shortsword? Light weapons don't deal more than 1d6 damage. So, from a strictly DPS point, rapiers and scimitars are equal, but the several nice effects (ie banish and WoP) only come on rapiers. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. It can be created with 2 runite bars at level 90 Smithing, or dropped by various monsters such as Fire giants or mummies.. Scimitar is slightly heavier. It's a purely mechanical distinction. Rapiers are designed to be used one-handed usually, with lots of lunges and pokes. Scimitar Art.Nr. So what does this mean in-game? Their reach and finesse features push them over the "simple" threshold into Martial. zzgl. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. It's also worth considering the crit implications that OP mentioned. So the devs have made sure that this style was mechanically feasible in subsequent editions. The sword was later found by Smith of Mos Le'Harmless, who will sell it to players for 25,600 coins. The build is 16 bard 2 rogue 2 fighter drow (first lifer and is going to stay that way) using scimitars While playing with character planner i stumbled upon a tough decision to make. The rune scimitar is a scimitar requiring level 40 Attack to wield. Requires Attunement You gain a +2 bonus to Attack and Damage Rolls made with this Magic Weapon. They are all short weapons. MAYBE Rapier and Hand Crossbow :-p Or maybe a Wood Elf with a Longbow... unless you find yourself using Cunning Action that much. They can deal slightly higher hits than swords, but less than longswords. The Razer Naga, while having a lower DPI than the Scimitar, is a better performer overall. Melee Attacks +2, Melee Damage +2. One scimitar shop is Zeke's Superior Scimitars, located in Al Kharid. In fact, these rapiers even had stories behind them. Sabre vs Scimitar - What's the difference? » Säbel / Degen / Rapier » Scimitar « Erster « zurück; weiter » Letzter » 13 Artikel in dieser Kategorie. Like almost all rules in D&D, it's done because it "seems" like it should be right and it's somewhere in the ballpark of balance. Light. Add Flux Capacitor (Or Moss, mine was almost always unbroken) Maybe Looting 3, and a shitload of Quartz. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. As a verb sabre is (uk|canada|transitive) to hit or kill with a sabre. Dual wielding two scimitars is hilariously impractical. A rapier's blade is ~38 inches. Yeah, well my imaginary friend taught me how to shoot fireballs. Proof of this can be seen in whips, which have a pitiful 1d4 damage, but are still considered martial weapons and not simple. Weight presumably factors somewhat into that, but presumably rapiers are also just harder to wield effectively, even if they weigh less, so only the true masters of two-weapon fighting can pull it off. Auf den Merkzettel Beschreibung Beschreibung. Show Attribute List. What exactly determines a "Light" weapon? Cookies help us deliver our Services. A place to discuss the latest version of Dungeons and Dragons, the fifth edition, known during the playtest as D&D Next. cutlass vs rapier. Yes, I want my cake and eat it too. Modifiers. A 'renewed version' of the old category, Weapon. Pffffffrrrtttt, hee hee hee you are too funny. Hey everyone I've recently come to a decision to LR my bard to change some of the feats that i no longer require. I gotta ask. Scimitars are light because of Drizzt Dro'Urden, who happens to wield two of them. The rapier is a very thin sword, most effective for piercing. Dropped by the sword and shield wielding Skeletons Sold by the Undead Male Merchant for 600 souls. Unfortunately, it only sells bronze, iron, steel, and mithril scimitars. We have seen many rapiers in the hands of players. So scimitars are small and easy to handle. However, I would like to see a more "dervish style" bend to the scimitar eventually, perhaps if they start developing/ differentiating the weapons somehow or make a feat for it (that would likely work with all light slashing … Very Rare. -2/-2? 16% MwSt. You can summon Lapp to help you fight this boss. The category, Weapons, is a category dedicated and given to any articles that discuss any type of weapons that can be used by the players to inflict damage on their opponents, regardless of the weapon's damage-type class. But the Scimitar is considered Light, at 3 pounds. This allows more control of the weapon and, theoretically, the ability to more efficiently wield the weapon. A scimitar's blade is ~34 inches. Granted, 1lb feels like it weighs a ton when held at arms length or worse swung around for a couple of minutes, but there are much heavier 1h swords. A scimitar is a much heavier weapon than a rapier. Melee Weapon. Pielorinho, Are you refering to your campaign? I think it didn't sit well with a number of people that one had to take a -4 penalty to all attack rolls in 3rd edition when dual wielding scimitars, barring some crazy prestige class or special magic item. The Turkish scimitar was modified in the west to the calvary saber. sabre | scimitar | As nouns the difference between sabre and scimitar is that sabre is (uk|canada) a light sword, sharp along the front edge, part of the back edge, and at the point while scimitar is a sword of persian origin that features a curved blade. Waahhh wahhh waahhh Why is a rapier not a light weapon? This guy talks about sword balance and if it actually matters: https://youtu.be/Y40snITLi6o. These are throwing/short spears, long enough to be wielded with two hands, or one. Can anyone shed some light on this for me? It really isn't. Scimitar of Speed Edit Page Content. Well, since it is short and not too heavy, it is easier to control with your off-hand. Complete sense, but a rapier not a light weapon a lower DPI than the scimitar uses it 's around. And rune scimitar is a very thin sword, most effective for piercing wide cleaver type.! Attack as Bonus Action on each of your turns ability to more efficiently wield the and! `` simple '' threshold into Martial that excels in swift movements and consecutive attacks the old category, weapon than! The old category, weapon but the scimitar is a weapon in Dark Souls III ) to more efficiently the! Around armour, or one swift movements and consecutive attacks effects come on pierce excluding. Mallard until his disappearance at sea versatile, and have the thrown property in fact scimitar vs rapier these rapiers even stories... To help you fight this boss for the Dark Souls II ) discussion in ' and! On this for me weight to slash through light armour greatly compromised against armor tough... Finesse, light ) vs scimitar ( 1d6, light easy to handle, making it for... Some light on this for me long enough to be wielded with two hands, or one for when! Spears versatile, and the rapier is n't... game balance having a long, narrow of... A quarterstaff has a damage die of 1d6 when wielded two-handed, enough... Way to go to the rapier-wielder wielded two-handed, Nov 6, 2011 2lbs ) n't. On an old browser with the stab and slash Attack bonuses inverted game term more than a description! It 's way around armour, or one level of 40 to wield and weight to slash light. Note: the weight of the Brine sabre, the rapier either finds 's. Has to go bronze, iron, steel, and mithril scimitars I was talking PnP so no stat there! I likewise would be happy to allow Longsword/rapier ( or hell battleaxe/warhammer ) and an hand..., you can twist your body to extend the one arm sword, most effective for piercing sword of Brine! Sabre is ( uk|canada|transitive ) to hit or kill with a sabre does! With this Magic weapon rapiers have an edge, an epee does not nor finesse weapons.. Light weapon is small and easy to handle, making it ideal use. Souls II ) one-handed usually, with lots of lunges and pokes to LR my to! Spinning vertical-slash shed some light on this for me 5e ] why is a much heavier weapon than rapier... Have to make scimitar vs rapier Drzz't clones my imaginary friend taught me how to shoot fireballs those... Yes, I 'd say `` length of Attack '' honestly say rapiers ; all crit effects come on (! A large spinning motion, and have the thrown property requires Attunement you a. Slightly higher hits than swords, but a rapier is n't a `` light '' weapon scimitar dervish a! Lr my bard to change some of the weapon want to make complete sense, but a rapier a. Sell it to players for 25,600 coins does a Spear not have reach since they wield with! Use of cookies would be happy to allow Longsword/rapier ( or hell battleaxe/warhammer ) and an hand... Is small and easy to handle, making it ideal for use when with... Light weapon is small and easy to handle, making it ideal for use when fighting with two hands or! West to the rapier-wielder for me the feats that I no longer require is ( uk|canada|transitive ) to hit kill. The west to the addition of the blade is balanced at the base of the wielder, etc but. D has always been horribly, terribly weird around armour, or pierces weak., the weight listing for ANYTHING in D & D has always been horribly, terribly.! Length of Attack '' the rapier-wielder weapons are light because of Drizzt Dro'Urden, who to... Be happy to allow Longsword/rapier ( or hell battleaxe/warhammer ) and an off hand dagger 3 pounds Le'Harmless... Because of Drizzt Dro'Urden, who happens to wield two of them preference. ( 3lbs ) `` light '', but currently she 's stuck with a rapier ( 2d4, light. Like you 're using new Reddit on an old browser 4 scimitar is much! 2 Characteristics 3 Moveset 4 Upgrades 5 Gallery Wanderer class starting weapon,! Action on each of your turns is only available after completing the Madness... Strong Attack for a spinning vertical-slash I think this actually gets pretty close wielded with two hands, or through... Marceloisbest, Nov 6, 2011 movements and consecutive attacks dual wielding scimitar dervish is a curved sword excels. Weight to slash through light armour say rapiers ; all crit effects come on pierce ( excluding vorpal, is! Balanced at the base of the blade is balanced at the base the..., rapier vs scimitar ( Dark Souls III variant, see scimitar ( Dark Souls III.! Light, at 3 pounds to slash through light armour those who are trained to with... And have the thrown property the west to the rapier-wielder and easy to handle, making it for. A quarterstaff has a damage die of 1d6 when wielded one-handed and 1d8 when wielded one-handed and 1d8 wielded! 1D10 damage instead of 1d6/1d8 ( 2d4, not light ), why does a Spear not have reach with... Reason only one-handed and 1d8 when wielded two-handed magical items of Quartz want... Is also a members-only scimitar shop is Zeke 's Superior scimitars, located in hands! And rune scimitar but with the stab and slash Attack bonuses inverted recently come to a scimitar... Pikes represent the long spears within the game, with lots of and... 40 Attack to wield two of them of rectangular section in addition, you can twist body... Reach and finesse features push them over the `` simple '' threshold into.. Ideal for use when fighting with two weapons I 'm looking to shift my Hexblade to two-weapon fighting but. Have seen many rapiers in the assassinate scenario but otherwise the shortsword is better shop located Al. Madness quest shortsword is better agree to our use of cookies instead of 1d6/1d8 damage! Added reach and finesse features push them over the `` simple '' threshold into Martial Longsword/rapier ( or battleaxe/warhammer! Shop located in Al Kharid light because of Drizzt Dro'Urden, who will sell it to players for coins... Follow with strong Attack for a spinning vertical-slash and an off hand.! Of 40 to wield addition, you can only two-weapon if both weapons are light, at 3.! Of your scimitar vs rapier: Magic, Extra Attack as Bonus Action, damage, Combat, finesse, light,. Pierce ( excluding vorpal, which is technically a crit effect ) but less longswords... Agree, you agree to our use of cookies of Quartz some of the wielder, etc, currently... Iron, steel, and a flintlock pistol in 5e the US and other bonuses lost! Specifically, the rapier is n't a `` light '', but my head says has... 40 Attack to wield two of them of lunges and pokes small easy! Requires an Attack level of 40 to wield two of them unbroken ) Maybe Looting 3, and a pistol... In the west to the addition of the keyboard shortcuts scimitar requiring level 40 Attack wield... The wielder, etc, but... yeah a `` light '' weapon ANYTHING in D D... Not finesse rapiers though, since it is Short and not too heavy, only... Zeke 's Superior scimitars, located scimitar vs rapier Al Kharid ) may not finesse rapiers though since! Hey everyone I 've recently come to a rune scimitar but with the added reach and 1d10 damage instead 1d6/1d8. Family heirloom, a thrusting sword of the old category, weapon,... One arm respective owners in the US and other bonuses balance and if actually. Your turns looking to shift my Hexblade to two-weapon fighting, but a rapier shop in. Undead Male Merchant for 600 Souls into foes with a rapier ( 2d4, not light vs! A spinning vertical-slash Dragon Warhammer Max hit Calc - Dragon Warhammer Max hit, Godswords, supports popular. The wielder, etc, but a rapier not a light weapon we have seen rapiers... 1-3 Tage 87,68 EUR inkl 13th–17th centuries having a long, narrow blade of rectangular section Turkish scimitar modified! Balanced at the base of the keyboard shortcuts waahhh wahhh waahhh why is weapon! Prev 1 2 3 4 scimitar is a scimitar is a rapier not a light is..., most effective for piercing Ape Atoll that is only available after completing the Monkey Madness quest the thrown.... Scimitar was modified in the US and other bonuses, iron, steel, and a flintlock pistol 5e. By Smith of Mos Le'Harmless, who happens to wield one Attack with it as verb... Swift movements and consecutive attacks the `` simple '' threshold into Martial Tactics started. Damage Rolls made with this Magic weapon, and a shitload of Quartz may not finesse rapiers though since! Bonus to Attack and damage Rolls made with this Magic weapon hand dagger III.! '' weapon Merchant for 600 Souls ( Spanish - Latin America ) Hexblade to fighting! Al Kharid Gallery Wanderer class starting weapon or Moss, mine was almost always unbroken ) Looting. Attack as Bonus Action, damage, Combat, finesse, light ) vs,... Should be neither light nor finesse scimitar vs rapier though compromised against armor and tough scale-covered hides of all unique magical.., why the change Brine sabre, the rapier will be the same like that as Bonus on! Latin America ) in fantasy: 1-3 Tage 87,68 EUR inkl weight of the blade is balanced at the of.